Wednesday, January 23, 2019

Is the Sommelier Exam A Pour Decision?


When I told my dad that I was planning to sign up for the Introductory Sommelier Exam, his response was: “Great! Then you can get a job pouring wine in someone else’s restaurant.”

Point taken.

But it did get me thinking more seriously about the exam itself. Who takes it? Is it worth it if you’re not in the food & beverage industry? What’s the ROI if you are in the food and beverage industry?
Here’s what I found out:

About the Exam
There are several levels: introductory, certified, advanced, and master. Each level will cost you hundreds of dollars just to take the course and sit through the exam itself.

The first level is definitely not anything like what you saw in the movie Somm. It’s a 2-day course with master sommeliers, followed by a multiple choice exam about the different wine regions. There is a “low failure rate,” and you passing it gets you a lapel pin and certificate. Beer and sake are also included on this introductory exam!

It seems like over 90% of those who take the exam do have experience in the food and beverage industry, and are taking it to further their careers. However, there is a margin, like me, who wants to take the exam simply because we appreciate wine and want to learn from the masters.
Once you’ve passed the introductory level, each subsequent level recommends at least 1-2 years of straight up preparation. There will be blind tastings on each exam after introductory.

Oh, and in case you were wondering – the recommended reading for Level I includes Karen MacNeil’s Wine Bible (check!)

What’s a Master Sommelier?
A master sommelier has passed all four examination levels and guarantees to a potential employer that you are among the most qualified in the industry, with “outstanding tasting and evaluation skills, wine knowledge, and outstanding abilities in service and beverage department management” (MasterSommeliers.org). Only 274 people worldwide have received this title since its establishment in the 1970’s, and there are 182 professionals with this title in the U.S.

Only 29 of those are women.

Master Somms in the U.S. make on average $150K.

The certification is not required of success in this field, and requires an insane amount of time and money. Given that the vast majority of the most knowledgeable wine professionals in the world do not have this certification, do you think it's worth it? 


Ways to make drinking wine (and other alcohol) healthier


Ways to make drinking wine (and other alcohol) healthier

In response to a few conversations I’ve had with individuals in our class about the health effects of alcohol, I’m providing a short write up on a few of the methods I understand to reduce the long term damage done by drinking. This list is not exhaustive – I’ve tried to keep it simple rather than delve into the litany of compounds that show up in an Amazon search for ‘hangover cure’. Instead, this is a few of the best bang for your buck ideas to attenuate the long term effects of an occasional FOAM night.


1)      Get out there and run, lift weights, goat yoga, whatever.

It’s not news to any of you that exercise is important to your health. But did you know that the act of getting your heart rate up changes the way your body processes alcohol? There are a few different ways in which this happens:
·         Converting sugars: we know that a hard workout burns a ton of calories, but what if we don’t have that energy readily available from a recent meal? Our body is smart, it stores extra energy in the muscles and liver as glycogen, a carb storage tank that we often dip into challenging exercise sessions (think Barry’s or a quick Dish run). Wine contains sugar leftover from the fermentation process in varying amounts -- dry wines have less than an ice wine, but they’ve all got some. Drinking after a hard workout will ensure that some of the sugar from alcohol is converted into liver glycogen and thus spends less time hanging around in your body, which is great news.

·         Lowering inflammation to allow wine to be “heart healthy”: whether you believe it or not, we’ve all heard that red wine is “heart healthy”. However, when researchers introduced wine into some individuals lives and tracked their cholesterol, blood glucose, triglycerides, and C-reactive proteins (proxy for inflammation), there was no improvement. However, those who worked out twice a week saw significant benefit to health markers. So what gives? It turns out that exercise sets in motion a whole host of processes in our body that allow us to get the benefit out of wine, whether it’s red or white.

·         Keeping the brain healthy: Individuals who regularly binge drink, defined as 4+ drinks for women or 5+ drinks for men (a foreign concept to many of us) often see cognitive declines when this behavior is repeated over extended periods of time. However, individuals who exercised a few times a week and drank frequently were found to have significantly better brain health markers than those who drank but did not exercise.


2)      Don’t drink bad wine/alcohol (all the time)

Wine is similar to any other consumer product – up to a certain point, you get what you pay for. In order to compete on price, wineries are forced to take shortcuts. These cheaper mass growing ops are expected to make grapes for a few hundred dollars per ton. Some of those shortcuts may be additional spraying, fewer soil /water tests, and adding in flavoring agents. Recently, there was a lawsuit in California, after testing found that a wide variety of cheap wines (think Beringer, Charles Shaw, Franzia, Sutter, etc.) had up to 5 times the level of arsenic allowable in typical drinking water. Before you stress out: unless you’re drinking wine like you drink water, it’s probably not enough to cause serious damage. But it does go to illustrate the quality control tradeoffs that come with producing cheap wine.


3)      When you’re drinking above average amounts, give your body above average nutrients

You probably wouldn’t go into an important interview or test without at least considering your caffeine consumption / meal beforehand. So then why do so many of us go into a night of heavy drinking with no strategy other than maybe an ill supported  plan of ‘carb loading’? Processing alcohol takes nutrients, often ones that we don’t get enough of to begin with…and certainly don’t get at the right time, in the right dose. In order to help your body process alcohol, these nutrients need to be commensurate with consumption levels, and I haven’t seen a ton of folks chasing their tequila shots with green smoothies at the Patio.

No supplement or food will allow you to drink a couple bottles of wine and wake up feeling like sunshine. However, a few things will probably help your health in the long run if you’re a moderate to heavy drinker:

·         B complex vitamins (specifically B1, B12) – these are super important in our brains and bodies for the production of energy, and metabolizing alcohol burns through a ton of them. Consequently, these are best taken alongside alcohol when your body needs them most.
·         Electrolytes – think Pedialyte/coconut water, not Gatorade. Alcohol dehydrates you, and the best way to rehydrate is with a drink that closely mirrors the salt and sugar content that we have in our body. Don’t have any Pedialyte on hand? Eat some fruit and something salty with a few glasses of water before bed after a night out.
·         Healthy diet – I’m not going to tell you to give up that late night snack of choice. However, the healthier your diet is the rest of your week (think leafy greens, antioxidant rich berries, etc.) the better equipped your body will be to deal with and recover from the stresses of alcohol.

Disclaimer: This is intended to be somewhere on the two by two matrix of [informative vs interesting] between a Cosmo article and a research study. None of the above is intended as specific health advice.

Federal Government Shutdown Impact on Wine Industry

As the federal government's partial shutdown reaching its 33rd day (with no end in sight), we've seen the far reaching consequences, including long TSA lines, national park closures, cancelled State of the Union address, etc. In fact, the partial shutdown even affects the wine industry, as federal and state approval for: (1) starting a new business; (2) new or changed labels; and (3) ingredient changes.

Wineries typically submit approval for label changes ahead of their spring releases (a process that takes up to 36 days), and without approval from the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (which is closed), wineries are in limbo. While certain label changes are exempt (i.e. simply changing the vintage for already approved labels), the rollout of new wines will almost certainly be impacted. As a result, wine makers face a dilemma: go ahead with labeling and bottling with the risk that the labels will be later rejected, or delay bottling and release, thereby potentially impacting deals with retailers.

Just for a sense of the scale of the impact (just focusing on wineries; there are downstream ripple effects for distributors): 
  • Per WineAmerica, a trade association representing 600+ wineries, ~70% of respondents in a survey indicated that they are waiting on label approval
  • Per Wine-Searcher: In 2018, 192,000 labels made their way through the TTB's system
The impact is expected to be most acute for new / small wineries, who don't have a backlog of older vintages they can dip into. 

Sources: 
  • https://www.winespectator.com/webfeature/show/id/Your-Rose-May-Be-Late-this-Year
  • https://www.news5cleveland.com/news/state/ohio-wine-and-beer-industry-impacted-by-government-shutdown
  • https://www.wine-searcher.com/m/2019/01/us-government-shutdown-hits-wine-hard

"A glass a day keeps the doctor away" - Putting to bed some misconceptions about the health effects of wine

Two sources of inspiration for this post. First, not being a particularly good creative writer myself, my objective with my blog posts is not to entertain, but to inform (while doing some cool research myself). Second, after reading Amanda's illuminating research on sulfites, I was generally curious about the health benefits of drinking wine, and hopefully put to bed some popular misconceptions that I've had. Three of which are as follows:
  1. Drinking wine is fine, as long as it's in moderation - TRUE - According to the US Dietary Guidelines 2015-2020, drinking in moderation is defined as one drink per day for women, and two drinks per day for men. What is a "drink" in wine speak? The guidelines define it as 5 fluid ounces, which is just about half of our Gabriel-Glas wine glasses. Note: The guidelines do not specify whether you can carry over your 1-2 drink pass on days that you don't drink. Suffice it to say - not drinking all week and downing 14 glasses of wine at FOAM is likely not drinking in moderation.  
  2. White wine has less calories than red wine - FALSE -  Calories in wine is most directly influenced by its ABV (Alcohol by Volume) percentage. A higher ABV by 1 percentage point equates to ~12 more calories per glass. The average glass of wine has about 9-12% ABV, equating roughly to 110-140 calories. While white wine on average has a lower ABV than red wine, there are still high ABV, high sugar white wines that pack in more calories than even some of the heaviest red wines (e.g., US Moscato - 177 to 213 calories per glass)
  3. Red wine is good for the heart, prevents cancer, and prevents vision loss - KIND OF TRUE, BUT - Ok, yes, red wine has a compound call resveratrol, which has been proven to prevent bacteria and funghi, and protect against UV radiation. However, this health benefit comes from the skins of red grapes. Therefore, anybody can load up on the benefits of resveratrol by simply eating more grapes, blueberries, cranberries, and even peanuts - not more red wine. That said, if you had to choose amongst alcoholic drinks, red wine might be the best option. 
My takeaway from these findings - yes, there are proven health benefits associated with wine, we've all come across an article or two. But it's important to remember that wine is an alcoholic drink at the end of the day and it is no substitute for a well-balanced, nutritious diet. However, given the choice between your cocktail, wine, or beer ticket at next week's FOAM - there is a clear right answer. Cheers to that!

Sources

https://health.gov/dietaryguidelines/2015/guidelines/appendix-9/
https://www.shape.com/blogs/fit-foodies/best-wines-your-waistline
https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/265635.php

A $230,000 bottle of Wine

This week we read about Lafite, a brand I knew by name, and knew was one of the nicest, priciest bottles you can buy. This got me thinking, what is the most expensive bottle of wine ever sold? It turns out the highest price paid for a trio of bottles (I know, the 3 bottle thing is kind of a cop out) was $690,000, or $230,000 each. A collector bought the three bottles of wine, an 1869 Chateau Lafite, at an auction in Hong Kong in 2010. Originally, the bottles were expected to go for less than $10,000 each, so the result was quite surprising. What would prompt a collector to buy such an expensive bottle? What would the investor do with the bottles? Perhaps its a display of wealth and power? Or maybe the investor planned to drink 2 and save the 3rd? Did s/he really think the bottles would drink well (I can't imagine)? Whatever the motivation, it is an absurd amount of money to spend on a bottle of wine-turned-vinegar. I like wine, but not enough to spend hundred of thousands of dollars on a single bottle!

The 5 most expensive bottles sold at auction are:
5. Chateau Margaux 1787 - $225,000
4. Chateau Lafite 1869 - $230,000 (per bottle)
3. Shipwrecked 1907 Heidseck - $275,000
2. 1947 Cheval-Blanc - $304,375
1. Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 1992 - $500,000


Changes to liquor regulations- South Africa

Image result for south africa flag

Our discussion in class last week about wine regulations, got me thinking about other regulatory changes that have been made regarding wine in other countries. The country that quickly came to mind for me was South Africa. Having lived in South Africa for the first six years of my life, I was interested in seeing what has changed.

To my quick discovery, a lot has changed and a lot will continue to change. For instance, just this past summer, South Africa proposed a liquor products amendment bill. This bill seeks to amend the Liquor Products Act of 1989 and the Amendment Act of 2008. Under this bill, some of the key decisions were to include beer under the patrol of the Wine & Spirit board. The board will likely change its name to incorporate this. In addition, the bill has reduced the alcohol percentage that will classify the drink as a liquor product. Previously, alcohol content in beverages were allowed to be 1%, but the bill has changed this to be 0.5%. While the bill proposed to change the sell and intake of liquor from people under the age of 18 up to people under the age of 21, this was not passed.

The fact that regulations have recently changed, not only in the US but all over the world regarding wine and liquor in general, highlights the importance of keeping up with this ever evolving regulatory landscape that will impact wine businesses.

Wine´s Glass Ceiling

After the 2 classes, we have had, I reflected on the fact that both of our speakers had been women. As a woman in Business School, it is rare to find a class in which even one-third of the guest speakers are women, so I was happy to welcome what seemed like a change.
That led me to think that possibly this was an industry, were female leaders were more common - so I eagerly did some research. Boy, was I wrong.
A quick Google search on "Women in Wine Industry" led me down a rabbit hole of disheartening articles, denouncing the lack of female representation in this Industry. The irony of it all is that this is an Industry that thrives on marketing their products to women, and where women are one of their main consumers.

One of the quotes that particularly grabbed my attention noted that while the overall total female leadership in the industry is 10% (unsurprisingly low after reading many of the articles) there are ZERO female CEOs in wine companies that produce between 100K to 500K wine cases per year.
This is despite the fact that in many of the Viticulture and Enology courses in US university female students largely outnumber men.

While this trend is, unfortunately, found in multiple other industries, I think it is still an important figure to keep in mind as we read the cases in class and meet the speakers.

In case someone wants to take a look at some of the articles, I´m adding a couple of links below:

"Wine´s Glass Ceiling and the Winery Working to Shatter It": https://www.forbes.com/sites/kristifaulkner/2019/01/23/wines-glass-ceiling-and-the-winery-working-to-shatter-it/#6066f4e7314a

"Women and the Wine Industry" (Written by the author of The Wine Bible): https://winespeed.com/blog/2017/12/women-wine-industry/