Tuesday, March 12, 2019

WineInStyle: should Eberhart sell?


This case ends with a key decision point for Eberhart’s career. I would separate two aspects of the decision. First, I think that Eberhart needs to decide whether he wants to stay as in the business or not. If he decides to stay as Chairman, he faces a series of decisions of how to turn around the business. The case suggests that he has an idea of how to make this happen by cutting operational costs.

If he decides to leave, and sell his part, he needs to decide who to sell. In this scenario, I see the certification requirement as a no brainer. As Eberhart, due to moral reasons, I wouldn’t want to leave Khoo and the company in hands of investors that might do wrong to the company, even if he ends up receiving the money from them. I think that the downside of looking for a certification is very low compared to the huge upside of reassuring that the investors are who they say they are.

For me the toughest decision is the first one, which is if he wants to continue in the business or not. I would take a few considerations to make this decision. First, I would look at his personal situation. The case mentions that Eberhart wanted to spend more time in Palo Alto with his family. The second consideration is what is best for the business. If he does want to spend more time in Palo Alto, then maybe the position of Chairman is no longer suitable for him since it would require someone more in touch with the day to day business. Therefore, as Eberhart I might lean towards deciding to leave the business. Then I would do the certification; if the investors pass it, then I would sell to them, and if not, I would look for other investors.

No comments:

Post a Comment